min read

Should 50/50 couples get a prenuptial agreement?

Should 50/50 couples get prenups? We explore how financial equality intersects with marriage's legal framework.

Published by

Photo by Chester Wade on Unsplash

Some couples opt for the simplicity of splitting everything 50/50. While this arrangement may seem fair and straightforward, it brings up another important consideration: should a couple who divides their expenses equally also get a prenuptial agreement (prenup)?‍

What Is a Prenup and Why Does It Matter?

A prenuptial agreement is a legally binding contract signed by both parties before marriage. Its purpose is to outline how financial matters will be handled during the marriage and in the event of divorce. Prenups can address issues like property division, debt allocation, spousal support, and more. Popular prenup platforms like First work hand-in-hand with couples on all of these issues.

For couples who already split finances equally, the idea of a prenup might feel unnecessary. If everything is fair and equitable now, why complicate things with legal documents? However, relationships and circumstances evolve over time. A prenup can act as a safeguard against unexpected changes, ensuring that both parties are protected no matter what happens.‍

The Case for a Prenuptial Agreement

1. Life Isn’t Always 50/50

While splitting finances equally may work at the start, life has a way of introducing complexities. What happens if one partner loses their job, takes time off to care for children, or faces a significant health issue? Suddenly, the 50/50 dynamic may no longer be feasible. A prenup can account for these possibilities, providing clarity and a sense of security if circumstances shift.‍

2. Protecting Premarital Assets

If one or both partners bring significant assets into the marriage, a prenup can ensure those assets remain separate. For instance, one partner might own a home, have a robust investment portfolio, or hold intellectual property rights. Even in a 50/50 arrangement, these premarital assets could become a point of contention during a divorce without a prenup to define their status.‍

3. Debt Protection

Not all financial matters involve assets; some involve liabilities. If one partner has significant student loans, credit card debt, or other financial obligations, a prenup can protect the other from being held responsible. Even when splitting expenses equally, debt incurred before or during the marriage could become a shared burden without a clear legal framework.‍

4. Clarity on Financial Contributions

A prenup can also outline how financial contributions are handled in scenarios where equality is harder to achieve. For example, if one partner’s income is significantly higher than the other’s, it may be worth addressing whether expenses will still be split evenly or proportionally. Having these discussions before marriage can prevent misunderstandings later.‍

5. Minimizing Conflict During Divorce

Divorce can be an emotionally charged and financially draining process. Even couples who split finances equally during the marriage may face challenges dividing assets equitably during a divorce. A prenup can simplify this process by clearly defining how assets and debts will be handled, reducing the potential for disputes.‍

Balancing Financial Equality and Legal Protection

For couples who pride themselves on splitting everything equally, the idea of a prenup may seem contradictory. After all, if both partners are on the same page financially, shouldn’t that eliminate the need for legal precautions? The reality is more nuanced.

A prenup isn’t just about anticipating divorce; it’s about setting clear expectations and protecting both partners in a variety of scenarios. For example, if one partner’s financial situation changes significantly, a prenup can provide a framework for how to adapt. Similarly, if the couple decides to start a business, invest in property, or have children, a prenup can address how these decisions will affect their financial arrangement.‍

Key Considerations When Deciding on a Prenup

If you and your partner are considering whether to draft a prenuptial agreement, here are some important factors to keep in mind:‍

1. Open Communication

The decision to get a prenup should be a joint one, based on open and honest discussions about your financial goals, expectations, and concerns. Transparency is key to ensuring both partners feel heard and respected.‍

2. Legal Advice

If desired, both partners can seek independent legal counsel when drafting a prenup. This helps offer another layer of confidence that the agreement is fair, legally enforceable, and tailored to your specific circumstances.‍

3. Future Planning

Consider how your financial situation might change over time. Will one partner be taking on more financial responsibilities? How will you care for your pets? A well-drafted prenup should account for these possibilities.‍

4. Emotional Readiness

It’s important to approach the prenup discussion with sensitivity and understanding. Acknowledge any concerns or fears your partner may have and focus on how the agreement can benefit both of you.‍

To Prenup, Or Not To Prenup?

For couples who split everything 50/50, the decision to get a prenup isn’t always straightforward. On one hand, the default law may seem sufficient. On the other hand, life’s uncertainties and the complexities of marriage can make a prenup a valuable tool for protecting both partners.

Ultimately, the decision comes down to your unique circumstances, values, and goals as a couple. By having open conversations, seeking professional advice, and considering the potential benefits and drawbacks, you can make an informed choice that sets the foundation for a strong and secure partnership. Working with a prenup platform like First can give you and your partner confidence that you are entering into your partnership in a respectful, responsible, and planful way.

Timeline for Getting a Prenuptial Agreement: What to Expect

Understand the step-by-step process and timeline for creating a prenuptial agreement before marriage.

Education

min read

What Is a Prenup, and Do I Need One?

Learn the ins and outs of prenups—including why they can actually help your marriage in the long run.

Trends

min read

Why is full financial disclosure important for a prenup?

Full financial disclosure ensures fairness, transparency, legal validity, and prevents future disputes in prenups.

Law Demystified

min read